Clarinet vs. Saxophone Embouchure

/ Clarinet, Clarinet Embouchure, General Woodwind, General Woodwind Embouchure, Saxophone, Saxophone Embouchure, Technique, Woodwinds

Clarinet vs. Saxophone Embouchure for Band Directors

Who

This issue affects band directors teaching clarinet and saxophone players, from middle school beginners to advanced students, in school or community ensembles. Clarinetists and saxophonists need distinct embouchure guidance to achieve proper tone and intonation.

What

The challenge is understanding and teaching the differing embouchure requirements for clarinet and saxophone, single-reed woodwinds with unique lip placement, tongue positioning, air stream, and instrument angle needs. Incorrect application of one instrument’s embouchure to the other leads to poor tone and intonation.

Why

Clarinet and saxophone embouchures differ due to their bore shapes and mouthpiece designs, as noted in The Art of Saxophone Playing. Clarinet’s cylindrical bore and smaller mouthpiece require a “teeth on top” embouchure with a high, back tongue and cool air, while saxophone’s conical bore and larger mouthpiece demand a flexible tongue and warm air. Applying clarinet’s tight embouchure to saxophone causes biting, and saxophone’s relaxed embouchure on clarinet produces airy tones.

Where

Embouchure adjustments are applied via:

  • Clarinet: Top teeth on mouthpiece, lower lip over bottom teeth, tongue high/back (cat hissing), cool air (like blowing on coffee), 30–45-degree angle.
  • Saxophone: Top teeth on mouthpiece, lower lip over bottom teeth, tongue low for low notes and higher for high notes, warm air (like fogging a mirror), 45–60-degree angle.

When

Address embouchure differences in:

  • Beginner Instruction: When teaching middle school students to establish correct habits.
  • Lyrical Passages: In clarinet pieces like Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto or saxophone jazz charts like In the Mood, requiring distinct tone qualities.
  • Technical Sections: In runs needing stable intonation, such as in Holst’s First Suite in Eb.
  • Ensemble Tuning: In rehearsals where clarinet sharpness or saxophone flatness affects blend.

How

To teach proper embouchure:

  1. Teach Clarinet “Vee” Setup: Have students say “vee” to position top teeth on mouthpiece and raise tongue high/back, ensuring a focused airstream.
  2. Emphasize Clarinet Angle: Check for a 30–45-degree angle to align airstream, avoiding a horizontal position that disrupts tone.
  3. Guide Saxophone Flexibility: Encourage a relaxed lower jaw, lowering tongue for low notes (e.g., low Bb) and raising it for high notes (e.g., high D).
  4. Use Long Tones: Practice long tones on both instruments, checking tongue position and angle with a mirror to reinforce habits.
  5. Check Intonation: Use a tuner to monitor pitch (A=440 Hz), addressing clarinet sharpness or saxophone flatness from improper embouchure.
  6. Contrast Air Streams: Teach cool air (clarinet) for focus and warm air (saxophone) for projection, practicing with exercises like Klose’s Daily Studies.
  7. Annotate Repertoire: Mark parts for clarinet and saxophone to emphasize correct embouchure in pieces like Sousa marches.

Conclusion

Clarinet’s “teeth on top” embouchure with cool air and steep angle contrasts with saxophone’s flexible tongue, warm air, and horizontal angle. By teaching proper lip placement, tongue positioning, air stream, and instrument angle, directors can prevent tone and intonation issues. Through long-tone exercises, tuner checks, and repertoire annotation, directors ensure clarinetists and saxophonists deliver clear, in-tune performances, enhancing the ensemble’s sound.

Scroll to Top